Tahoe Lawyer

September 28, 2001

Beach access countersuit to be filed; District chooses defense council

By Rick Adair, Bonanza Staff Writer

A countersuit aimed at keeping local beach access restricted will be filed by next week, according to Incline resident Maryanne Ingemanson.

Ingemanson is spearheading the grassroots response to the case filed by 2001 Beach Access, Inc., against the Incline Village General Improvement District in July, citing concerns that Incline property values would drop if access is widened. The case seeks to widen the access to Incline and Burnt Cedar beaches for property owners within IVGID who are excluded because of a 1968 deed restriction.

2001 Beach Access attorney Stephen Mollath said the group, incorporated by Incline resident Chuck Bluth, wants to gain access to Incline and Burnt Cedar beaches for property owners within IVGID who are excluded.

Attorney Mike Johnson, who represents Ingemanson and others in the matter, said his clients had grown weary waiting for 2001 Beach Access attorney Stephen Mollath to include them as parties to the suit.

Addressing the IVGID Board of Trustees Wednesday, Ingemanson said, "We gave Mr. Mollath a stipulation to sign by Sept. 21, and he hasn't done so."

But in later comments, Mollath said he was awaiting IVGID's response to the suit before deciding the status Johnson's clients, who include Ingemanson's Village League to Save Incline Assets, Inc., Incline resident Tom Menning, and Incline company Circle I, L. L. C.

"IVGID won't meet on this until at least Oct. 1," said Mollath, "It depends on how the talks go with them on how we decide to package things. It's simply a procedural matter."

IVGID will begin deliberating on the case in October when open meeting law changes become effective that allow closed, confidential litigation discussions. In preparation for this, the board unanimously chose Reno legal firm Woodburn and Wedge to represent IVGID based on the recommendation of a selection committee.

"Ted and I agreed Woodburn and Wedge was the right choice," said Board Chair Kinsman, who served on the selection committee with Trustee Ted Fuller, General Manager John Danielson and General Counsel Scott Brooke. "What swung it for us was the firm's good, strong real estate experience, its work with water districts, .. and its class action experience in north Nevada. We felt ... it was a good match for (IVGID)."

Also considered were the firms Lemons Grundy and Eisenberg, and Thorndal Armstrong Delk Balkenbush and Eisinger. The latter successfully defended IVGID in a 1999 wrongful termination case.


Copyright North Lake Tahoe Bonanza. Materials contained within this site may
not be used without permission.